A Tidal Wave of Support: 16 Allies Join CPRC’s Supreme Court Fight for Parental Rights in Foote v. Ludlow
The Development at a Glance
The battle for parental rights has reached a critical moment at the U.S. Supreme Court. In our landmark case, Foote v. Ludlow School Committee (Docket 25-77), CPRC is challenging a school policy that inserts state ideology between parents and their children. Now, a powerful coalition has joined our fight, filing 16 amicus briefs that send an unmistakable message to the Justices: the nation demands that the Court act to protect children and reaffirm the constitutional rights of parents. Critically, the Court itself has signaled strong interest by relisting the case four times—a significant development that indicated the Justices are giving this monumental fight the serious consideration it deserves.
This coalition's support highlights the case's national importance: Preventing schools from imposing ideology that conflicts with family beliefs.
Why This is a Pivotal Moment
This tidal wave of support is exceptionally rare. Of the thousands of petitions the Court receives each year, only a handful attract this level of unified support, demonstrating the profound national importance of this fight. These briefs, which can cost tens of thousands of dollars each to produce, represent a massive investment from allies who see Foote as the critical case to stop school secrecy policies nationwide. Combined with the Court’s four relists—a clear indicator the Justices are engaged in a serious debate about granting review—this momentum positions CPRC at the forefront of a potentially transformative victory for American families.
What It Signals
Relists (four so far) suggest at least some Justices are intrigued, possibly debating a grant or soliciting Solicitor General views. Historically, relisted petitions have a higher grant rate (over 30% vs. 1% overall), indicating potential for resolving circuit splits on parental exclusions in education.
A Powerful Coalition on the Front Lines
The groups standing with us form a powerful, diverse coalition from every sector of American life, proving the fight to protect children transcends politics. Our allies include:
- State Governments: A coalition of states led by Montana, emphasizing federalism and state interests in family law.
- Policy and Legal Institutes: Respected scholars from the Manhattan Institute, Goldwater Institute, and Independent Women's Law Center who argues schools' actions undermine due process.
- Medical and Psychological Experts: Experts like Dr. Erica E. Anderson (transgender care specialist) and America's Frontline Doctors, highlighting health risks of unvetted affirmations.
- Parental and Rights Groups: Groups like Parental Rights Foundation, Our Duty-USA, and NC Values Institute—focusing on real-world harms to families.
- Religious and Liberty Organizations: Organizations like Samaritan's Purse, Advancing American Freedom, and National Legal Foundation—defending faith-based objections to indoctrination.
This diversity—spanning law, medicine, education, and faith—bolsters the petition's credibility, showing Foote isn't isolated but a flashpoint for nationwide concerns.
CPRC's Role and the Bigger Picture
“This overwhelming support validates the fight CPRC has been waging in the courtrooms across America: that parents—not government schools—have the fundamental right to direct the upbringing and care of their children,” said Vernadette Broyles, CPRC President and Chief Counsel. “The Constitution is on our side, and this coalition is making that case powerfully to our nation’s highest court.”
A grant could dismantle affirming policies nationwide, putting districts on notice that constitutional rights trump ideology. With relists ongoing, this support positions CPRC for a transformative win.
The Path Forward
If granted, Foote could set precedent protecting millions of families. CPRC is prepared for merits briefing, leveraging these amicus insights. But opposition briefs may follow—sustained resources ensure we prevail.
Join the Fight
- Donate Now: Empower CPRC to capitalize on this momentum in SCOTUS and beyond. Donate now.
- Share This Analysis: Amplify on X and Facebook.
Our Commitment
CPRC was founded to ensure no family stands alone against ideological overreach. This amicus surge proves we are not alone in this fight. The Constitution stands with us, and so does the growing national movement.