Pain, Confusion and Compassion: How the US Has Reached a Trans ‘Tipping Point,' New York Post, Benjamin Ryan

In an October 2024 article for the New York Post, Benjamin Ryan covers how the issue of pediatric gender-transition treatments has taken center stage in America’s legal, medical, and cultural arenas. With increasing scrutiny and restrictions across many states, the future of these controversial interventions for minors hangs in the balance.

Mounting Legal Challenges

‍The U.S. Supreme Court is expected to rule on Tennessee’s ban of puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones for minors, with legal experts predicting the state will prevail. Such a decision could accelerate the rollback of pediatric gender treatments in nearly half the country.

International Warnings Ignored

European nations, citing weak evidence and concerns over long-term harm, have moved to severely restrict these treatments. In contrast, many U.S. medical organizations continue to promote early medical intervention, despite growing controversy and pushback.

Medical Field Under Pressure

‍As lawsuits, subpoenas, and critical research intensify, even providers in states without bans are pulling back. A new analysis shows a drop in prescriptions for minors in most of these states in 2023, indicating a cautious shift.‍

The Role of Detransitioners

Lawsuits by detransitioners—individuals who regret undergoing medical transition—are rising, with potentially devastating financial and reputational consequences for providers. These stories are increasingly shaping public opinion and fueling demands for accountability.

Institutional Credibility at Stake

The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and WPATH are under fire following leaked documents and allegations of political manipulation. State attorneys general are signaling legal action, and a growing number of medical professionals are quietly retreating from this practice.

What Lies Ahead

‍CPRC President Vernadette Broyles states, “At some point the sheer weight of human suffering caused by these mistreatments will force a reckoning.” As the cultural pendulum swings, the push for transparency, caution, and child-centered care is gaining momentum.

______________________

Source: Ryan, Benjamin. “Pain, Confusion and Compassion: How the US Has Reached a Trans ‘Tipping Point.’” New York Post, 21 Oct. 2024, nypost.com/2024/10/19/us-news/pain-confusion-compassion-how-the-us-has-reached-a-trans-tipping-point/.

Photo: Jasper Colt, USA TODAY, as published by New York Post

‍